Medicare Advantage: Privatization, then Fraud, and Soon Fiscal Impact

Medicare Advantage (MA) program, launched in 2003 as a market-based alternative to traditional Medicare, has evolved into what critics describe as one of the largest corporate fraud schemes in U.S. history. Through systematic upcoding, favorable selection tactics, and aggressive lobbying efforts, private insurers have extracted over $600 billion in cumulative overpayments from the Medicare Trust Fund, accelerating the program's insolvency timeline while generating unprecedented profits for Fortune 500 corporations.

The Origins and Growth of Medicare Advantage

Legislative Foundation and Market-Based Vision

The Medicare Advantage program was established through the Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act (MMA) of 2003, representing a fundamental shift toward privatization of Medicare benefits. Policymakers envisioned that private insurers could administer Medicare more efficiently than traditional government-run programs, theoretically producing savings while offering beneficiaries supplemental services such as prescription drugs, vision, and dental coverage (Commonwealth Fund, 2017; Schaeffer, 2023).

Initially, participation remained low, prompting Congress to substantially increase payments to private insurers in 2006. These generous subsidies catalyzed explosive enrollment growth, with participation doubling from 5.8 million beneficiaries (14% of Medicare population) in 2005 to 11.7 million (25%) by 2010 (Biles et al., 2017; HHS ASPE, 2023). By 2024, MA covered over half of Medicare's 66 million beneficiaries—more than 33 million Americans—at an annual public cost exceeding $500 billion (KFF Health News, 2024; Public Citizen, 2024).

The Medicare Trust Fund Structure and Congressional Intent

When Congress established Medicare in 1965, lawmakers deliberately structured the program around a trust fund mechanism modeled after Social Security to ensure dedicated, protected financing for healthcare benefits. The Medicare Hospital Insurance Trust Fund operates as a specialized account within the U.S. Treasury, designed exclusively to pay Medicare benefits and administrative costs (Medicare Rights Center, 2025; Social Security Administration, 2025).

Congress chose the payroll tax model over general revenues, setting the initial Hospital Insurance tax at 0.35% of wages shared equally between employers and employees. This trust fund design created a firewall protecting healthcare funds from diversion to other government purposes while providing transparency about the program's long-term fiscal health through annual trustee reports (Social Security Administration, 2025).

Systematic Fraud and Manipulation

Upcoding: The Central Fraud Mechanism

Medicare Advantage plans systematically inflated government reimbursements through "upcoding"—artificially inflating or falsifying diagnoses to exaggerate enrollee illness severity. Federal audits identified widespread examples, including providers diagnosing pneumonia without testing and insurers coding HIV for 18,000 patients who received no HIV-related treatment, generating approximately $3,000 in extra payments per diagnosis (Medicare Rights, 2024; NPR, 2022; PMC, 2021).

Many plans relied on risk assessments performed by subsidiaries they owned, with little or no medical follow-up. The HHS Inspector General found that such assessments produced $7.5 billion in unwarranted payments in 2023 alone, highlighting the systematic nature of these fraudulent practices (HHS OIG, 2024; Medicare Rights, 2024).

Favorable Selection and Discriminatory Practices

Insurers employed "favorable selection" tactics, strategically enrolling healthier seniors while screening out high-cost enrollees. Department of Justice complaints revealed that major insurers including Aetna, Humana, and Elevance used call-routing systems and filters to divert disabled or costly individuals away from enrollment (CEPR, 2025; DOJ, 2025; Urban Institute, 2024; WHA, 2025).

These discriminatory practices allowed insurers to maintain artificially low costs while maximizing federal reimbursements based on supposedly sicker populations, creating a double benefit that significantly inflated profits at taxpayer expense.

Industry Capture and Obstruction of Oversight

Regulatory Capture and the Revolving Door

From its early years, the insurance industry paired systematic fraud with aggressive obstruction of government oversight. When CMS attempted to implement a regulation in 2014 requiring insurers to identify and repay overcharges, the insurance industry launched a coordinated resistance campaign. Officials reported industry "uproar" and "stakeholder pushback" that led CMS to withdraw the proposal without public explanation (CBS News, 2024; Fierce Healthcare, 2014; KFF Health News, 2024).

The "revolving door" phenomenon reinforced this systemic capture. Senior CMS officials routinely left the agency for lucrative insurance positions, then used insider connections to block audits. Most notably, Marilyn Tavenner, who headed CMS during the 2014 withdrawal, later became CEO of America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP), earning over $4.5 million annually (KFF Health News, 2024).

Legal Obstruction and Political Mobilization

Industry obstruction extended beyond lobbying to include systematic legal challenges. Insurers filed years of technical protests, claiming CMS audit methods were "flawed and unfair," while arguing they could not be penalized for violating rules CMS had drafted but never finalized (CBS News, 2024; KFF Health News, 2024).

Insurers also weaponized their beneficiaries as political shields, mobilizing over 33 million enrollees to flood lawmakers with opposition to oversight measures. Front groups such as the Better Medicare Alliance spent tens of millions on political advertisements, including a 2022 Super Bowl commercial urging Congress to "don't cut Medicare Advantage" (Medicare Advocacy, 2024; Public Citizen, 2024).

Corporate Structure and Market Concentration

From Individual Schemes to Fortune 500 Dominance

Medicare Advantage fraud spans the entire healthcare organizational spectrum. Individual physicians engaged in small-scale upcoding schemes, while mid-sized regional firms like Independent Health used subsidiaries such as DxID for large-scale diagnosis manipulation (Healthcare Dive, 2025; PMC, 2021).

At the apex, Fortune 500 corporations dominate the market. UnitedHealth Group—the fifth-largest U.S. company by revenue—faces lawsuits alleging it defrauded Medicare of over $2 billion (CBS News, 2024). Humana, subject to multiple audits, allegedly overstated patient severity to improperly collect $200 million in a single year (NPR, 2022). CVS Health (Aetna) and Elevance Health exploit vertical integration to maximize profit extraction across the healthcare delivery chain (Fortune, 2023).

By 2024, just seven corporations controlled 84% of all MA enrollment, creating unprecedented market concentration that reinforced the industry's ability to shape policy and suppress accountability (Public Citizen, 2024).

Financial Impact and Scale of Waste

Annual Overpayments and Cumulative Losses

Independent analyses confirm the enormous financial burden of MA overpayments. The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) estimated that Medicare would overpay private insurers by $84 billion in 2025—approximately 20% more than necessary (Healthcare Brew, 2025; MedPAC, 2025). Other studies place annual waste as high as $140 billion (Medicare Advocacy, 2024).

These overpayments compound annually, with cumulative losses since the program's large-scale expansion exceeding $600 billion. Projections indicate $1.2 trillion in excess spending between 2025 and 2034, losses that exceed the value of Medicaid cuts Republicans propose over the same decade (CRFB, 2025; Public Citizen, 2024).

Comparative Analysis with Federal Agency Budgets

The scale of Medicare Advantage overpayments dwarfs entire federal agency budgets. The annual $84 billion in overpayments exceeds the FBI's fiscal year 2025 budget of $11.3 billion for all national security and law enforcement activities by more than seven times (FBI, 2025). It surpasses the Environmental Protection Agency's $10.99 billion budget for nationwide environmental protection by nearly eight times (EPA, 2025).

These overpayments also exceed critical education investments. The annual waste could fund NASA's entire $25.4 billion space exploration budget more than three times over, or provide Pell Grants to twice as many students as the current program serves with its $38.1 billion annual cost (CBO, 2025; NASA, 2025).

Unprecedented Industry Profitability

Medicare Advantage has become among the most profitable sectors in the U.S. economy. In 2021, gross margins averaged $1,730 per enrollee, compared to $745 in the individual insurance market and $689 in the group market (KFF, 2025). By 2023, margins approached $2,000 per enrollee, far outpacing other insurance markets (CEPR, 2025).

Over the last decade, revenues of the largest MA firms rose more than 345%, outpacing most Fortune 500 sectors. Meanwhile, traditional Medicare operates with administrative costs under 2%, while the U.S. healthcare system spends nearly five times more on administrative overhead than peer nations (Medicare Rights, 2024; PGPF, 2025).

Threats to Medicare Solvency

Accelerated Trust Fund Depletion

Medicare Advantage overpayments directly accelerate Medicare's insolvency timeline. The Medicare Hospital Insurance Trust Fund is projected to be depleted by 2033, three years earlier than previous projections, with Medicare able to pay only 89% of Part A benefits once reserves are exhausted (Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, 2024; Peterson Foundation, 2025).

MA overpayments impose immediate costs on all Medicare beneficiaries. MedPAC warns that Part B premiums will be $13 billion higher in 2025 specifically because of inflated MA spending, forcing even traditional Medicare beneficiaries to subsidize private insurer profits (Medicare Advocacy, 2025).

Bipartisan Congressional Alarm

Congressional leaders from both parties have expressed growing concern about Medicare Advantage's fiscal threat. Senators Elizabeth Warren, Ron Wyden, and Representatives Lloyd Doggett and Jan Schakowsky warned Congress: "Where there is widespread agreement is the need to address waste, fraud, and abuse by private, for-profit insurance companies" (Warren, 2025).

Even Republican lawmakers who originally championed Medicare Advantage now call for reforms. Senator Chuck Grassley stated: "Despite these oversight efforts, [Medicare Advantage Organizations] continue to defraud the American taxpayer, costing them billions of dollars a year. The apparent fraud, waste, and abuse at issue is simply unacceptable" (Grassley, 2025).

Senator Roger Marshall (R-KS) acknowledged: "Like Dr. Oz, I thought Medicare Advantage was a good thing when it came out. But, unfortunately, it's been manipulated. They found loopholes to manipulate and now we're spending probably $83 billion more a year on Medicare Advantage patients as opposed to if they had been on traditional Medicare" (JustCare USA, 2023).

International Comparisons and Alternative Models

Superior Outcomes at Lower Costs

International evidence demonstrates that privatized models like MA are both costlier and less effective than public alternatives. Peer nations including Germany, Switzerland, and Canada achieve superior access and outcomes at substantially lower per-capita spending (PGPF, 2025; PMC, 2013).

The United States spent $12,742 per person on healthcare in 2021, compared to $9,044 in Switzerland and $6,850 across wealthy OECD countries. Unlike Medicare Advantage, other nations constrain costs by linking spending to income growth, enforcing physician payment caps, and maintaining non-profit risk pools (PGPF, 2025).

Evidence of Deliberate Corporate Strategy

Intentional Fraud and Political Strategy

Court filings and internal documents reveal that Medicare Advantage fraud was not accidental but deliberate corporate strategy. Evidence includes executives laughing about "moronic" regulators and knowingly retaining overpayments they recognized as illegitimate (CBS News, 2024; WHA, 2025).

The Better Medicare Alliance and seven dominant firms waged a lobbying campaign exceeding $330 million over five years, hiring more than 300 lobbyists—over 220 specifically focused on MA matters. This sustained campaign prevented CMS from enacting stronger oversight rules and transformed MA into what watchdogs describe as a "politically potent juggernaut" (KFF Health News, 2024; Public Citizen, 2024).

Conclusion: The Capture of Medicare

The Medicare Advantage experiment has transformed from a policy innovation into a subsidized engine of corporate profit sustained by systematic fraud, aggressive lobbying, and regulatory capture. Through upcoding, discriminatory enrollment practices, and legal obstruction, private insurers have extracted hundreds of billions from the Medicare Trust Fund while accelerating the program's insolvency timeline.

Over two decades, Medicare Advantage has entrenched itself as both a massive fiscal burden and a formidable political force. The program's market concentration among seven dominant corporations, combined with sophisticated influence campaigns, has created unprecedented regulatory capture that protects fraudulent practices from meaningful oversight.

Unless comprehensively reformed, Medicare Advantage will continue draining public resources, weakening Medicare's financial foundation, and entrenching inequalities in America's healthcare system. The program's transformation from market-based efficiency mechanism to corporate profit extraction scheme represents a fundamental failure of privatization policy that demands urgent corrective action.

References

Advisory Board. (2023). The 42 healthcare companies on this year's Fortune 500. Advisory Board Daily Briefing. https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2023/06/07/fortune-500

Better Medicare Alliance. (2024). Understanding a recent analysis of gross margins in Medicare Advantage. Better Medicare Alliance. https://bettermedicarealliance.org/blog-posts/understanding-a-recent-analysis-of-gross-margins-in-medicare-advantage

Biles, B., Pozen, J., & Guterman, S. (2017). The evolution of private plans in Medicare. The Commonwealth Fund. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2017/dec/evolution-private-plans-medicare

CBS News. (2024). Feds killed plan to curb Medicare Advantage overbilling after industry opposition. CBS News. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/medicare-advantage-overbilling-feds-kill-bill-after-industry-opposition

Center for Economic and Policy Research. (2025). Alleged kickbacks further expose Medicare Advantage corruption. CEPR. https://cepr.net/publications/alleged-kickbacks-further-expose-medicare-advantage-corruption

Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. (2024). Analysis of the 2024 Medicare Trustees' Report. https://www.crfb.org/papers/analysis-2024-medicare-trustees-report

Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. (2025). Medicare Advantage will be overpaid by $1.2 trillion. CRFB. https://www.crfb.org/blogs/medicare-advantage-will-be-overpaid-12-trillion

Commonwealth Fund. (2017). The evolution of private plans in Medicare. Commonwealth Fund. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2017/dec/evolution-private-plans-medicare

Congressional Budget Office. (2025). The Pell Grant Program: Funding and current shortfall. https://www.cbo.gov/system/files/2025-04/61366-Pell-Grant-Program.pdf

Department of Justice. (2025). The United States files false claims act complaint against three national health insurance companies and three brokers alleging unlawful kickbacks and discrimination against disabled Americans. DOJ Press Release. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/united-states-files-false-claims-act-complaint-against-three-national-health-insurance

Environmental Protection Agency. (2025). FY 2025 Budget Overview. https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2024-04/fy25-cj-00-overview.pdf

Federal Bureau of Investigation. (2025). A review of the President's fiscal year 2025 budget request for the Federal Bureau of Investigation. https://www.fbi.gov/news/speeches-and-testimony/a-review-of-the-president-s-fiscal-year-2025-budget-request-for-the-federal-bureau-of-investigation

Fierce Healthcare. (2014). Feds killed plan to curb Medicare Advantage overbilling after industry opposition. Fierce Healthcare. https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/payers/feds-killed-plan-curb-medicare-advantage-overbilling-after-industry-opposition

Fortune. (2023). CVS Health, UnitedHealth, and the rise of vertically integrated U.S. healthcare. Fortune. https://fortune.com/longform/cvs-health-unitedhealth-group-us-health-care-system-mergers

Grassley, C. (2025, February 25). Top Senate Republican demands answers on Medicare Advantage billing from UnitedHealth Group. Star Tribune. https://www.startribune.com/top-senate-republican-demands-answers-on-medicare-advantage-billing-from-unitedhealth-group/601227896

Healthcare Brew. (2025). Medicare Advantage may cost the government $84b more than traditional Medicare in 2025. Healthcare Brew. https://www.healthcare-brew.com/stories/2025/03/18/medicare-advantage-cost-government-84-billion-2025

Healthcare Dive. (2025). Independent Health settles with Justice Department over alleged Medicare Advantage upcoding. Healthcare Dive. https://www.healthcaredive.com/news/independent-health-doj-settlement-medicare-advantage-upcoding

House Budget Committee. (2024). Social Security and Medicare continue on path to insolvency, trustees confirm. House Budget Committee Press Release. https://budget.house.gov/press-release/social-security-and-medicare-continue-on-path-to-insolvency-trustees-confirm

Internal Revenue Service. (2025). Internal Revenue Service Program Summary by Budget Activity. https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/266/15.-IRS-FY-2025-BIB.pdf

JustCare USA. (2023). Attention mounts on Medicare Advantage fraud and abuse. https://justcareusa.org/attention-grows-on-medicare-advantage-fraud-and-abuse/

Kaiser Family Foundation. (2025). Financial performance of Medicare Advantage, individual, and group health insurance markets. KFF. https://www.kff.org/medicare/financial-performance-of-medicare-advantage-individual-and-group-health-insurance-markets

Kaiser Family Foundation. (2025). Medicare Advantage insurers report much higher gross margins per enrollee than insurers in other markets. KFF. https://www.kff.org/affordable-care-act/medicare-advantage-insurers-report-much-higher-gross-margins-per-enrollee-than-insurers-in-other-markets

KFF Health News. (2024). The Medicare Advantage influence machine. KFF Health News. https://kffhealthnews.org/news/article/medicare-advantage-cms-overcharges-lobbying-unitedhealth-lawsuit

Medicare Advocacy. (2022). Senate Finance Committee holds hearing on Medicare solvency. Center for Medicare Advocacy. https://medicareadvocacy.org/senate-finance-committee-holds-hearing-on-medicare-solvency

Medicare Advocacy. (2024). Medicare Advantage payment rates for 2025 released. Center for Medicare Advocacy. https://medicareadvocacy.org/medicare-advantage-payment-rates-for-2025-released

Medicare Advocacy. (2025). Overpayments and other structural imbalances favor private Medicare Advantage plans. Center for Medicare Advocacy. https://medicareadvocacy.org/overpayments-and-other-structural-imbalances-favor-private-medicare-advantage-plans

Medicare Payment Advisory Commission. (2025). Report to Congress: Medicare payment policy. MedPAC. https://www.medpac.gov/document/mar-2025-report-to-the-congress-medicare-payment-policy

Medicare Rights Center. (2024). Annual assessment and new investigation highlight high Medicare Advantage overpayment. Medicare Rights Center. https://www.medicarerights.org/medicare-watch/2024/08/22/annual-assessment-and-new-investigation-highlight-high-medicare-advantage-overpayment

Medicare Rights Center. (2024). Watchdog estimates $7.5 billion Medicare Advantage overpayment from questionable health risk assessments. Medicare Rights Center. https://www.medicarerights.org/medicare-watch/2024/10/31/watchdog-estimates-7-5-billion-medicare-advantage-overpayment-from-questionable-health-risk-assessments

Medicare Rights Center. (2025). Medicare financing: Shifting the focus to sustainability in addition to solvency. https://www.medicarerights.org/policy-documents/medicare-sustainability-financing

NASA. (2025). FY 2025 Budget Agency Fact Sheet. https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/fy-2025-budget-agency-fact-sheet.pdf

NPR. (2017). Medicare failed to recover up to $125 million in overpayments from private insurers. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/01/06/508260306/medicare-failed-to-recover-up-to-125-million-in-overpayments-from-private-insure

NPR. (2022). Medicare Advantage plans overcharged Medicare, audits show. NPR. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/11/21/1137500875/audit-medicare-advantage-overcharged-medicare

Peter G. Peterson Foundation. (2025). How does the U.S. healthcare system compare to other countries? PGPF. https://www.pgpf.org/article/how-does-the-us-healthcare-system-compare-to-other-countries

Peter G. Peterson Foundation. (2025). How is K-12 education funded? https://www.pgpf.org/article/how-is-k-12-education-funded/

Peter G. Peterson Foundation. (2025). Medicare's Hospital Insurance Trust Fund could be exhausted in 8 years. https://www.pgpf.org/article/medicares-hospital-insurance-trust-fund-could-be-exhausted-in-8-years/

PMC. (2013). Comparisons of health care systems in the United States, Germany and Canada. PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2690175

PMC. (2021). Upcoding Medicare: Is healthcare fraud and abuse increasing? PubMed Central. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8649706

Public Citizen. (2024). Medicare Advantage companies spend $330M+ to influence policy. Public Citizen. https://www.citizen.org/news/medicare-advantage-companies-spend-330m-to-influence-policy

Schaeffer, L. D. (2023). The Schaeffer Center for Health Policy & Economics. University of Southern California.

Social Security Administration. (2025). Trust Funds - Social Security history. https://www.ssa.gov/history/reports/trustees/historypt.html

Social Security Administration. (2025). What are the Trust Funds? https://www.ssa.gov/news/en/press/what-are-the-trust-funds.html

STAT News. (2025). Republicans long supportive of Medicare Advantage call for reform. STAT News. https://www.statnews.com/2025/05/01/medicare-advantage-justice-department-kickbacks-allegations

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, ASPE. (2023). Medicare Advantage overview: A primer on enrollment and spending. HHS ASPE. https://aspe.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/documents/9b42ffbf2341726d5b63a9647b0aad15/medicare-advantage-overview.pdf

Urban Institute. (2024). Favorable selection in Medicare Advantage? Urban Institute. https://www.urban.org/research/publication/favorable-selection-medicare-advantage

Warren, E. (2025). Warren, Wyden, Doggett, Schakowsky push congressional leadership to reject Medicaid cuts, crack down on Medicare Advantage upcoding. https://www.warren.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/warren-wyden-doggett-schakowsky-push-congressional-leadership-to-reject-medicaid-cuts-crack-down-on-medicare-advantage-upcoding

Wisconsin Hospital Association. (2025). DOJ: Large health insurers knowingly sent illegal kickbacks to Medicare Advantage brokers. WHA. https://www.wha.org/news/newsletters/2025/05-08-2025/1